Thems the breaks about binary choices. Kill Silas. Thats a tip for the very end-game top contents, like hunting Nemesis bosses. Is the talisman really awesome or I will find a better one soon (regretting my decision haha!) Bribe Silas to leave New Harbor. Alicia was very clear that no harm should come to Silas as she fears retribution. If so, you could read Grim Dawn A Detailed Analysis next. Valve Corporation. Ill split the tips into more than one article, to give some details on each part. Well, now im even glad with the mistaken choice. Is there any possibility to complete the burrwitch quest before and not kill him now? You kill the character, and then complain when bad things happen? At this point the player can either take mercy on the couple and offer them safe passage to Devil's Crossing or engage and kill them. You have delivered the scrap to Silas, ensuring that New Harbor does not suffer the wrath of the bandits. Please someone tell me it's going to be alright :(. You can craft so many things. You think your comment was so necessary that it warranted a 3-year necro bump? But hey, if he happens to know how to program real life, on-the-fly cause and effect consequences into video game AI, I imagine Crate, and others, would love to hire this guy :). A Family Crisis - Official Grim Dawn Wiki in: Quests A Family Crisis Edit This is a small Act 2 side quest that begins when you talk to Stephen Skinner after encountering him at his house in the Arkovian Foothills . This problem extend to the first playthrough, since you have nothing to start with. Things like Tainted Brain Matter, and Ancient heart and the like are precious little things, so use them wisely. First I ignored the village but went to kill cronley and everyone then came back to "save" the village. If they do not deliver enough scrap to Silas, their overseer, he will undoubtedly execute someone. You level up, youimmediately spend your point into Spirit or Cunning. If you ignore the village and kill Cronley, Silas leaves and then you get a reward. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. thats quest consequence for you. Except now that awesome drop isnt awesome anymore. If you don't kill Isaiah he will later appear in Homestead as a Special Goods vendor with his daughter Josephine. Alicia was very clear that no harm should come to Silas as she fears retribution. But the loot tables are shared among all monsters in the world, meaning that anything can drop anything, and there are no specific spot to farm any item. For example, consumables, powerfulMythical Relics, parts of legendary items sets and the most important components. Speak to Alicia afterwards. Kill Cronley, the Act 2 Boss. Edit: Killed that motherfucker Cronley and glad atleast the children survived.. damn. I chose to kill him, that way when he saw the smouldering, burning wreckage of his former base, he wouldn't try to axe everyone. Really, crafting a strong aspect of the game, that keep giving you candy along the way, but only gets to its full potential after hundreds of hours of gameplay. Good article, theres some good advice here. I usually only get junk. And be patient for the recipes as they come one by one. And if you cant stand few hits, you will have to start running to escape, and will stop doing damage. Plain and simple,Physique is the most important attribute. Okey so I recently picked up Grim Dawn and I'm shy of 7 hours into the game, really enjoying it, and got close to old Arkovia. Speak to Alicia afterwards. Always side with Anasteria unless you need to farm her items. huh, ive done it before, but not in this character. The thing is: Grim Dawn is really grim. If the player chooses to bribe him, he will go away after starting a new game session. You can choose either to kill him or strike a deal where he tells you the location of Cronley's secret aether crystal (check behind his bed). Silas fled before you had a chance to deal with him. The spiteful ghost of Cronley? Speak to Alicia afterwards. Grim Dawn Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. I thought it'd generally be better to kill him in Act 1 during Cultist's Orders so that he doesn't block the way over and over in subsequent Cronley runs, especially in ultimate, since I thought he'd just mostly slow down each run. You should let Alicia know that the outlaws will leave them alone from now on. Skills like Blast Shield from demotionalist , or Gaints Blood from Constalltions are very strong defense in tight situation where you cant do much. Yes. This is my first run through the game. You lose like 250 rep. Spoilers: Okay, I've missed the Scorv part. So I cant wait to see what the Forgotten Gods have to add to the game next. I usually forget about Silas and go directly after Cronley in every run, thought I would kill Silas first this time around. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. If you typically spent all first 70 points in Physique, its probably wise to not spend the rest immediately. Even if they dont give direct benefit to your build, using them for the stats is okay. I'm too intimidated to continue playing, need help, Scan this QR code to download the app now, TURNS OUT I'M A FUCKING IDIOT AND I HATE MYSELF. Dikkiedik October 10, 2016, 4:11am 2 Defensive Abilities. I don't know, it just kind of happened and now Alicia started being angry with me for some reason and I just ignored it, guess she was a bit surprised by my heroic act. For the latter part, you have a good chance for tainted brain matter to drop each time you fight him in Cronleys Hideout? But I have hits and misses. Dont be afraid of trying to craft basic gear though; the items with question marks in the default menu of the blacksmith, named Enchanted Mace and Enchanted Boots. Poor people though, I felt really bad after that. (Note that this option will provoke retaliation, killing everyone in New Harbor except the children in the follow-on quest). You will then need to fight him. I hope that you liked this article. This one sounds basic stuff, but it could get very tricky. (Note that this option will provoke retaliation, killing everyone in New Harbor except the children in the follow-on quest). Upon seeing the evidence, Direni has become violent and threatens the safety of the denizens of Devil's Crossing. Occasionally Id dip in MMOs, Simulation, or Strategy. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). Grim Dawn Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. The bandits have a stronghold on the Four Hills nearby that should have scrap. It feels to me like the odds of the key dropping are lower in higher difficulties, but I dont have a large enough sample to say for sure. There doesn't seem to be any . I see, that coincides with my personal experiences. Make sure to replace your low level equipments regularly with something with higher armor and decent stats. You will have to fight her as well, and she will drop the Reddan Memento Ring. Silas - Official Grim Dawn Wiki in: NPCs Silas Edit Silas is an NPC located in New Harbor and the target of the quest Paying Tributes . Only thing I want to add is that, I think, the Ashes expansion added a potion that lets you repec your attribute points. Think the answer to all those is no. All rights reserved. Cant beat that. Everybody's moved on, and so should you. Ultimate = boss in Cronleys Hideout (rep farming and some loot). Nothing happens if you let him live, he just disappears. Yep, this was a surprise for me because I had no idea it would happen and didn't think Cronley would respond that fast considering I went after him right after killing Silas. Grim Dawn. I put it further down the list because its not mandatory in Normal and Elite. You can go back to Devil's Crossing to confront Direni. Contents 1 Campaign 2 Quotes 3 Dialogue 4 Gallery Campaign After you find Cultist Orders, the side-quest A Cultist in the Midst begins. Showing 1 - 5 of 5 comments Astasia Jan 21, 2016 @ 10:26am Direni got a pathetic drop table. If they do not deliver enough scrap to Silas, their overseer, he will undoubtedly execute someone. Kill Silas. All of your choices can be changed later in higher difficulties. 7 Javierkid 3 mo. He says he was travelling with his partner and a cart full of salvaged scrap. Pay him 2500 Iron and he will be only too happy to move on. Keep in mind many choices in this game have consequences down the road.. some big and some small. So, as you know, there's a guy name Silas in the Town camped by refugees being extorted by Cronley. Killing Silas will unlock the quest For the Children. This is an Act 2 side quest given by Alicia in New Harbor, a small village located southeast of the Old Arkovia Rift gate. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Dont neglect other important defenses to do that though. I usually try to just be patient about Strange Key if I didnt get one already (never factored that into the appeal of keeping him alive or killing him). Kill Cronley, the Act 2 Boss. For instance, the traitor in Devil's Crossing might appear in Cronley's hideout, depending on what option you choose when you expose him. The matter is: If you dont have the specific gear the build asks for, you either ask the guide writer to suggest you a beginner alternative, or dont do this build. Kill Silas. Then go back to the vilalger to collect your reward. I usually forget about Silas and go directly after Cronley in every run, thought I would kill Silas first this time around. Like Vitality damage builds, and retaliation builds, also solider shield builds are very strong and Crucible viable in general. She asks you to collect the missing scrap in the village's stead. Didn't know that would end up in the small village's destruction. Larkin asks that, should you run into a man named Isaiah, to kill him on his behalf. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. You have slain Cronley and scattered his gang. You must eliminate him before anyone gets hurt. You may still choose to kill Silas after. But Max these out by the time you get Ultimate, it will be very useful. It decreases the need to spread your attributes points around and gives you a better idea of where you really need to spend your points. I thought itd generally be better to kill him in Act 1 during Cultists Orders so that he doesnt block the way over and over in subsequent Cronley runs, especially in ultimate, since I thought hed just mostly slow down each run. I explored the area a bit and found this little place called "New Harbor" and talked to some of them, when I found Alicia and her daughter. With her people spread thin trying to collect enough fish for the tribute, they have fallen behind on their scrap collecting. Isaiah Reddan can be found just a little further along the road. If you kill them you get small optional dungeon that can be farmed (eventually up to nemesis level) If you stay with them, you get: - full quest chain with quest rewards (on Eliter and Ultimate last quest reward is guaranteed legendary item) Wow. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). On elite and ultimate I tend to just go with the story line and keep him or drop him depending if I get the key from normal progress. You have the spiritual guide, an NPC who can reset your skill points and devotion points, so you can spend them elsewhere. If you are going to run Cronley more than 7 times, its worth it to leave Demetri alive for rep, otherwise kill him. It makes maxing your resistances much smoother. The dungeon is not very interesting. Otherwise, the player would fight him, and Alicia will give the quest For the Children. However, with PC games, unless the dev puts a timer on it(hate those quests personally) it's going to have to go to one state or the other. You can accept his word or ask for half his profits in exchange for letting him live. So, I decided to spare Frankie "The Knife" up until he told me about Cronley's secret behind his bed. Objectives Rescue Oscar Jr. and Judith from Cronley's Hideout. You just need scraps and gold, and some courage to go through the randomization. If this were a tabletop, then rushing through might have worked since the DM would grasp the speed that you responded. Killed that motherfucker Cronley and glad atleast the children survived.. damn. Yeah, I noticed that! Silas fled before you had a chance to deal with him. You may still choose to kill Silas after. Hyliph 2 yr. ago Direni is dead and John Bourbon of Devil's Crossing will surely want to hear an explanation. Go against them on the 2nd. I usually do Cronley runs more for dynamite than anything else though. Bribe Silas to leave New Harbor. Thats content worth long hundreds of hours. I still think in vanilla terms though. Speak to Alicia about the good news. So let me get this straight. Deliver the Scrap to Silas at New Harbor. It kind of touched me so, well, of course I wanted to help them. It begins when you find Drew Larkin in the Arkovian Foothills. These faction gear require some effort to get, but its fun and very rewarding to do. Bribe Silas to leave New Harbor. Adding another mastery depends on your direction, or respec to another build entirely, Grim Dawn is flexible like this. Valve Corporation. You can refuse, but that just stalls out the questline until you accept, I think. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). After delivering the Scrap and receiving the XP reward, you can talk with Silas again and choose to kill him. When talking to Silas you can choose to deal with him in one of three ways: Alternatively, kill Darius Cronley before speaking to Silas and Silas will flee. Objectives: Kill Direni. Darkest Dungeon 2 reintroduces a Hero from the previous game,, Heres the guide on how to solve the Chamber of, A comprehensive Guide to March 7th, and how to use, Honkai: Star Rail Welt Build Guide Well discuss how, Honkai: Star Rail Seele Build Guide Well discuss how, Honkai: Star Rail Sampo Build Guide Well discuss how, V Risings Secrets of Gloomrot expansion gets more details, including, A comprehensive guide to Yanqing, and Ice DPS that specializes, Grim Dawn Tips I wish I knew before playing Part One, Party Combinations Guide: Magic, Physical and Mixed, Divinity Original Sin 2 Builds: Eternal Warrior, Star Wars Jedi Survivor Chamber of Reason Solution (Jedi Chamber Guide), Star Wars Jedi Survivor Chamber of Connection Solution (Jedi Chamber Guide), Darkest Dungeon 2 Adds Yet Another Fan-Favorite Hero, Though He Doesnt Look so Good. The quest will only activate if you talk to him and offer hope and safety in Devil's Crossing . After getting the info, you can still choose to kill him if you wish. I do Fan fiction, forums Role Playing, and guides for games. Its true, expansion offer a solution, but my Tips are aimed at Vanilla. If choose to kill Isaiah you will have the opportunity to fight him. In The Lost Elder quest you can lie keeping the relic with you Bone Talisman, apparently the only "bad consequence" of this is not getting 500 reputation with the Rovers.I don't care, just get enough by killing undead. And there are some where I have a level 85 character in ultimate that has yet to encounter a single damned Strange Key in that difficulty and maybe wishing I just got it from Direni. Speak to Alicia afterwards. Side with Barrowholm on your first character. You have slain Cronley and scattered his gang. You have slain Silas, liberating New Harbor of the bandit influence. Bring the cultist note to him. Things like Polished Emerald , Spellwoven Thread , and Vicious Jawbone can be a source for some attributes early on. You have opted to slay Silas rather than perpetrating the extortion happening at New Harbor. It was still on fire later. Talk to Alicia again for the reward. You might find a good accessory that needs five more spirit points or something. Someone's gonna have to explain this to me (Cronley/Town). Originally posted by Vel medvdek: It is (gameplay wise) similar choice as with Outcast. Pay him 2500 Iron and he will be only too happy to move on. Confront Direni at Devil's Crossing. She has asked you to collect the missing scrap in the village's stead. You encounter Drew Larkin dying on the side of the road. You can see a full list of all components and what they do here. Late reply, but the most obvious assumption: The bandits had spies/traitors INSIDE the village itself. These are some quick concepts of varied basic builds in Vanilla to look forward. Side with Order of Death's Vigil the first time. Kill Silas. It not only gives flat numbers in health (which can be multiplied by various ways), but the best defensive armor requires so many points spent on Physique maybe even All points in it. ArganVain 7 yr. ago 1 Thus, the majority of the build guides out there are aimed towards experienced players, with long hours into the game, and decent stash of equipment ready to be used. very important to not get 1 hit by the toughest bosses. Alicia begs you to rescue them. History After choosing to rescue Julius and Helen, the player is not granted any quest, experience, nor reputation. Do Kymon's on your 2nd character. He will sell various rare components like Focusing Prism and Blessed Steel. Its also worth mentioning this game is on a huge sale now on Steam (75%) , and expansion on (25%) for 48 hours. Arab hardcore PC gamer, Im from Egypt, and Ive been gaming on PC and writing since 2003. 1. I bee-lined it straight for their camp, leaving a path of complete and utter destruction, clearly feeling the need to quickly save those people. The game makes it clear to you that if you kill a character, there will be consequences. Keep in mind many choices in this game have consequences down the road.. some big and some small. Background Someone in Cronley's Gang witnessed the killing of Silas, and arrived shortly after you left to take revenge on the fishing village, killing everyone and taking the children to Cronley's Hideout. Ohh thx didnt know about the wikia! Killed Silas by mistake. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. not quite 3 years yet so he's good :P Nothing like a bit of necrophilia on a cold christmas morning. Well it seems that he hates Devils Crossing and John Bourbon more than anything but the Bloodsworn were a little bit to extreme for him so he joins Cronley at the end, He dropped 2 or 3 legs for me yesterday farming for rep and a ring. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, translation missing: en.js.preloader_text, strange key, which opens the iron door for Depraved sanctuary. Really? Give him the Scrap. You can actually get some solid gear from them to cover any weakness your character have. Killed Isaiah Redden. Its good on one side, as it make you keep playing the game, go wherever you like, and enjoy all the content without worrying about the drops, since what you get here would be the same as you got there. That and I was sure the devs would pull some sort of stupidity if I chose to stop the game there (come back to flaming ruins). Its a sure way to not get hit by a crit, and also have enemies miss some hits on you. You have bribed Silas to leave New Harbor alone. Before the Grim Dawn, Direni was a prisoner there. Just that. Then, because I am the source of morality, and everything I do is clearly just, I killed him. That key that mentioned above has a very little chance to drop from the cultist mobs near the depraved sanctuary if it is not changed, Also he is in hero classment which may increase the chance of an item you looking for. Killing Silas will unlock the quest For the Children. Max out Resistances, that will take care of most damage types. Which means you canvirtually go crazy and make what you like, and change it all later. Alicia from New Harbor in Old Arkovia. The enemies can be really weak on normal/Veteran, but become way stronger in Elite, and a total nightmare in Ultimate. Deliver the Scrap to Silas at New Harbor. By end game, you realize that attributes cant be refunded and new gear needs different distribution. But before we all get too excited about the future of Grim Dawn, I wish to share some few precious tips Ive learned along my journey in Cairn that I wished Id known them before I started playing. Never did that. Her village is being extorted by the nearby bandits and the quota for their deliveries keeps increasing. Ignore Silas. I've never been to Cronley's bed, but I just found a bed with a glowy circle around it sitting out in the middle of Four Hills. I usually do Cronley runs more for dynamite than anything else though. I feel like there's an option that could be included that would be the "best" option and it's just not included because they want the atmosphere of the game to be helpless but with all possibilties for this scenario it just seems unrealistically helpless for the sake of being helpless. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. But having played this game over 400 hours, I can totally confirm the viability of the method. Turns out she's a slave and wanted me to give Scraps to this douche with an accent he was a damn idiot so I decided to, uh, well, kill him. 3 Samoth95 7 yr. ago Except, y'know, not being a dick. If the player choose to deliver the Scrap to Silas, he will remain in New Harbor. Alicia says her people have fallen behind in collecting scrap, and fear the repercussions. The Three are a buncha fraudulent a-holes, but after getting their stolen thrones back, they're probably gonna be invested in eliminating the Ch'thonian presence on Cairn. Thats where it gets tricky, you are level 20, and you get a nice drop which makes you all excited, but sadlyyou cant equip due to lack of Spirit, or Cunning. What i dont get is (maybe bcs i am not from english speaking country and missed something), he is Chthonic agent (Cultist Orders - Salazar, Blade of Chthon) but later he is Aetherial boss. Pay him 2500 Iron and he will be only too happy to move on. Is that a deliberate choice, like does fighting him over and over there have a chance to drop something good? If you accept, you can just go warn her, but she's killed eventually and ends up in Barrowholm. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews . Grim Dawn is a rich world, with countless possibilities to replay the game and having different experience. You can customize and tweak every aspect about your character, when you first level up, or later. Bribe Silas to leave New Harbor. You should let Alicia know of your actions. You're locked into helping them at this point, at least on this difficulty, and Larria dies whether or not you kill her yourself. I wish I had seen this post earlier. So dont rush maxing all skills, but instead increase mastery bar early on. Some bosses debuff your resistances, so having some extra reserve is always a good thing. But notice that you dont have to follow any of these suggestions, you can actually start the game and level with one mastery through the normal difficulty, then depends on your taste, decide where to go from there. I killed him. Extort him. Its all designed to give you freedom, and encourage experimentation. Regret doesnt feel good, does it? Objectives Deal with Isaiah Reddan. Circuit-Breakers This is a term people use on skills that proc when player Health gets to a certain point (40% for example) and pop up some temporary strong defense buff or shield. It might be wiser to plan your second character based on what you already have from first playthrough, not on what you wish/expect to have. Normal/Veteran and Elite difficulties = revealed and killed in A1 Devils Crossing (exp and DC rep at the moment) All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Valve Corporation. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! 2. abluejelly 4 yr. ago. You have delivered the scrap to Silas, ensuring that New Harbor does not suffer the wrath of the bandits. Who set it on fire? They are not part of any hidden quest line, either. I always whoop him on normal, bonus DC reputation and Blood of Chthon are more worthy then those few reputation points. https://grimdawn.gamepedia.com/Quests spikenik August 2, 2019, 5:59am #3 Mornay does actually have a lootable corpse, but I don't remember it dropping anything particularly special. He was imprisoned for refusing to obey orders. Over-cap your resistance. These guidelines are only for those who dont like to feel overwhelmed by the amount of customizations the game have. Frankie "The Knife". A group of survivors in New Harbor are being forced to work for Cronley's gang, and the quota for their deliveries keeps increasing. These are not strictly magic items. You will later have to face Isaiah's daughter Josephine Reddan, who will be waiting in turn for revenge across the bridge to the Rocky Coast. No matter what level you are (beyond the first ten or twenty), you always need to prioritize defense. Yes, when I first heard this tip from professional players, I thought it sounded counter-productive, and boring, and that it would make progression slower. I am on act 2 and there is a guy called Silas, ive read some information about that mission, i really wanna save the village and let them live in a peace or i want to recruit them for DC, any help and tips will be nice. I joined Fextralife by Jan 2018, to share my views and ideas on the hobbit we all enjoy and love, Gaming. The next expansion, Forgotten Gods, wasannounced earlier this month, and is due to be released on Steam and GoG in second half of 2018. Kill Silas and end his tyranny over the fishermen. The first expansion (released October, 2017) brought some interesting features like new classes and the entertaining Fashion Dawn. Frankie "The Knife" is NPC located in the Four Hills. I was surprised to see some videos of endgame Cronley runs where players chose to keep Direni alive to fight him over and over and over in Cronleys Hideout. If so I might want to keep him alive in future sessions, at least for ultimate. Be it faction, or some random trader you murdered on the road, you have a second and third chance to rectify your choices. I explored the area a bit and found this little place called "New Harbor" and talked to some of them, when I found Alicia and her daughter. Direni is a man who lives in Devil's Crossing. However, the player may now learn of their history back in Devil's Crossing. You will then need to fight him. If you agree to avenge him, he will grant the quest. This is an Act 2 side quest given by Alicia in New Harbor, a small village located southeast of the Old Arkovia Rift gate. The exception is some rare items called Moster infrequents or MI, which are moderately good items dropping from some specific bosses or monsters, and are okay for leveling, not top end game though. Invest in Health, health is an all around decent defense against all types of enemies. A subreddit dedicated to Grim Dawn, an action role-playing game developed and published by Crate Entertainment. Always side with Anasteria unless you are doing the one specific build that needs her helmet. People mostly keep him alive to farm rep faster, but not because of the loot. With her people spread thin trying to collect enough fish for the tribute, they have fallen behind on their scrap collecting. Alicia from New Harbor in Old Arkovia. Ignore Silas. The bandits have a stronghold on the Four Hills nearby that should have scrap. Talk to him and you will be presented with several options. There's no incentive to not kill him. When it seems I have an option for things like that I look it up online before making a decision. You have slain Silas, liberating New Harbor of the bandit influence. I didnt think of it from a rep standpoint to kill him over and over. I keep him alive in Ultimate for an extra hero to get more rep for Cronley to help unlock Fabius and for more loot. Leave the last ten or twenty points free until you get to Max level and have all the equipment you need. Then again I never did like fighting Fabius and a most of my endgame characters dont even have nemesis reached with Cronleys crowd. Silas is an NPC located in New Harbor and the target of the quest Paying Tributes. You should let Alicia know that Silas is appeased. Attributes gives small bonus to damage, health, or mana, but their main value is being a requirement for armors and weapons. Talk to him and you will be presented with several options. Its one time use and you only get it from certain side quests, so still need to be careful with how you spend the points. The things he did as a bandit. Note that Silas will run away upon knowing Cronley is dead. So now he's dead and I don't plan doing multiple . Guide Isaiah Reddan can be found just a little further along the road. Then you spend one more hour, and your are level 30. The better decision is clearly to kill them all. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. In other words, many builds are gear dependent, which might not be friendly for beginners. So, as you know, there's a guy name Silas in the Town camped by refugees being extorted by Cronley. I Kill everyone that I am allowed to, as I like to keep the population down. I even tried a second time. This greatly disappointed me as well. All rights reserved. You get one precious attribute point each level, which you can spend on Physique, Cunning, or Spirit. With some playthroughs, I get the key right smack in Burrwitch Outskirts at the precise time I want it. Never kill Derini. You have bribed Silas to leave New Harbor alone. Right. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. She asks you to collect the missing scrap in the village's stead. Even in normal you can encounter some hard to pass encounters as a glass cannon.
Food Packing Cover Printing, Articles S