I found fluorphlogopite in some highlighters; one blush; six shades of ABH Sultry (Pearl, Steampunk, Bloom, Cinder, Teak, Cyborg); and six shades of ColourPop Brown Sugar (Chai, Jamocha, Amber, Ginger, Henna and Choc). Besides their website, products are available at ULTA Beauty, Disney Store, Revolve, and ColourPop Alipay Mini App. There is also a final report on the safety of synthetic fluorphlogopite, which is also known as synthetic mica (CosIng database results for synthetic fluorphlogopite here). Don't miss it Eyeshadow primer:." Light Plus, Neutral undertones. The CIR also has a report on the safety of certain borosilicate glasses, including calcium sodium borosilicate, which is commonly used in cosmetics, including many favorite sparkly eyeshadows. I have never been dissatisfied and will forever support ColourPop cosmetics. 2023 Cond Nast. A wag once said, The more I learn, the confuseder I get. How true. Lippie Pencil - ColourPop | Ulta Beauty Hi Christine have been reading up about ingredients diligently ever since I discovered this post. Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. Readers often ask me what are my absolute, all-time favorites, and now you can find my current and long-time favorites all in one place! For example, ColourPop includes the warning "not intended for use in the immediate eye area" with their Pressed Glitters, which have been included in various palettes alongside eyeshadows and Pressed Pigments (another product "not intended for use in the immediate eye area"). Glitters are not eye safe and it drives me nuts when I see companies (like ColourPop) put glitters in eyeshadow palettes especially ones that are aimed at more juvenile customers. This post is focused on the first concern as I recently had to go to an eye doctor after-hours to have a plastic particle removed that had gotten stuck to my upper eyelid immediately after I removed my makeup (not during wear) that would not flush out at home. That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. Are you having doubts about purchasing ColourPop? So a humidifier on my desk and constant eye drops and my eyes were finally moist enough to do the surgery again. Rare Beauty Warm Wishes Effortless Bronzer Stick Swatches, Sephora Collection Colorful Blushes Swatches (2023), elf Halo Glow Contour, Highlight, Blush Beauty Wand Swatches, A Pink & Plum Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, A Tropical Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, ColourPop x Harry Potter Collection Yer a Disappointment, ColourPop. So, I didnt want people to take what happened to me and run with it in an alarmist way either so I tried to present ALL the information possible so that it can be more about readers armed with whatever info is available and making the decision based on their personal comfort level. We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when The own thing that I wonder about is that if an eyeshadow palette is being sold with a color that states not to be used on the eye due to the glitter, what in the world do they expect you to use it for? Combination skin. Cant even answer a simple question when theyre the ones that messed up. Is polyester glitter safer than PET glitter? Hyaluronic acid is one of the ingredients found in this product, and it is used as a humectant to help your skin hold on to water. If you have any queries about ColourPop or their products, there are several ways that you can contact the support team. Ill need to weed out shadows with glitter or microglitter fallout and just keep the ones that are formulated to stay on well. Flakes can fall into the eye, get into the tear film and irritate your eyes. I think if enough people did and the companies understood clearly just how much business they might be losing, things might change. Especially since a good amount of glittery stuff seems to be marketed heavily towards that age catchment. I wish I could be of more help! I have had friends who werent as affected as I was with dry eyes, so its worth looking into some more of you still are considering the procedure. Sadly, I do believe that this is what it will take in order for cosmetics companies to quit pushing the limits of safety vs. marketability. Fortunately, I walked away with minimal damage (antibiotics for a week and skip contacts for a few days), so I consider myself lucky and definitely think getting to the doctor sooner (about two hours) was the right move! I love Colourpop eyeshadow palettes, and eye makeup! The buttery matte and shimmering metallic finishes highlight and control the shape of your eyes while emphasizing the bone structure and, at the same time, adding a softening effect to your upper lids. I tried eye drops just to see if maybe my eyes were dry or something and they just felt odd. Additionally, the formula actually went on smoothly and was . Value 56. The purple liquid liner is perfection. However, larger-sized Synthetic Mica and Borosilicate products are currently permitted. It is more important to notify the FDA of a reaction than the brand as brands are not required to report back to the FDA. behind and appreciate your patience! Why does one brands Pressed Glitter come with a warning but another brands does not? Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! Are you having doubts about purchasing ColourPop? I thought it was important to share because it can and does happen, so its not a would never happen to me! kind of thing either because sometimes I see people using well, Ive done it forever and never a problem as justification for why someone else should feel comfortable about it. Your California Privacy Rights. They have strict guidelines for what color additives can be used in cosmetic eye makeup. Also, dont use craft glitter in place of cosmetic-grade glitter! So while it appears to be similar to eyeliner, it definitely isn't the same and shouldn't be used interchangeably without taking the proper steps to ensure that you're using them safely. Thank you very much for your well researched piece, Christine. "Colors intended for use around the eye have to be specially approved by the FDA.". We've done a little digging about the newest trend, so that you don't have to. ColourPop Lippie Pencil Liners Matte Vegan Vault Cruelty-Free Warms Cools NWOB $8.79 to $13.79 SPONSORED ColourPop TRUTH OR BARE Lippie Pencil Vault Set 10 Lip Liners - BRAND NEW $49.95 or Best Offer SPONSORED Barbie x ColourPop Lux Lipstick Kit GOLDEN BEACH New In Box - Liner & Lipstick $18.99 Free shipping or Best Offer SPONSORED Suitable for every skin tone, our ColourPop eyeshadow review found that this pigmented eyeshadow palette offers a range of color combinations to create that perfect eye look you have always wanted. Glad I normally prefer satin or matte finishes anyway. Also, I hope youre healing well. User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and comment policy may be Your eyes never look irritated in your photos, and Ive often wondered how you use and remove so much makeup every day with seemingly no eye or skin irritation. Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Oh my gosh Brenda. Lip Sets; Liquid Lipsticks; Lip Lacquer; Blotted Lip; Lip Crme; Glowing . Eye Makeup Remover. I just cant risk it, but I have no problem with the other alternatives. Keep in mind, however, that the CIR is not a regulatory body and was originally established by the industry trade association (currently known as the Personal Care Products Council); they have a set of procedures that they say keeps their review process independent from the Council and the cosmetics industry. This list is useful in particular for anyone who is concerned about Pressed Pigments (not glitter) as you can look up the various pigments used in a particular shade to see if it is approved for eye usage or not. It doesnt apply to every shade from Pat McGrath, but they have used it before! "These higher amounts are necessary so that the lip liner doesn't dry out your lips but can cause irritation and discomfort to the skin around your eyes.". 33 [deleted] 3 yr. ago not sure why you're being downvoted, because you're right. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Youre an absolute pearl. The lip stains (bought cherry pop and another deep color) have absolutely no pigment and look like nudes on my light olive tone skin. But if you insist on trying this lip liner TikTok hack, be sure to sanitize it with a cleanser that has alcohol in it and, if it is a pencil, try using a sharpener to clear the pencil of any contaminants before using it on your eyes. Eyeliner | ColourPop Then soak my lashes with an additional cotton pad to get rid of the mascara. . Im waiting the answer for my request, the package got lost, and I dont know if you send it again, because I have not received the mail back. I have worn glitter products for years, too, on the lid as well as below the lash line (not the waterline) not always fully aware of the risks but quite aware of potential risks in the last few years. Yesterday I had a thought when I was struggling to find a hot-pink eyeliner: Could I just use a lip liner on my eyes? Get started with ColourPop today and find your favorite cruelty-free cosmetics products. Register. Im happy to get cruelty-free, vegan products at a reasonable price.I was told about this company by my then teenage daughter. retailers. The question is below, and the comment section of the blog has feedback, as well as the podcast. So, I waited for a good deal from Colorpop to get my products for a nice price and freeshipping. Since the company focused on cosmetics products for the face, lips, and eyes, the siblings expanded their reach and created two more brands Sol Body for body makeup and Fourth Ray Beauty for skincare products. . I have always gone for the expensive high end makeups but after Covid Ive been having to save where I can. The brand-new ColourPop Ultra Blotted Lip and new Blotted Lip shades will be available today at 10 a.m. PST on colourpop.com. I would've snagged . I have seen an indie brand say 008 Polyester Glitter as one of their ingredients. Ive been wearing heavy eye makeup for over 15 years, and this is the first time Ive gone to an eye doctor because something was stuck in my eye. SHANY Multi-Use Chunky Pencils for Eye Shadow, Eyeliner, Lip Liner, Lipstick - W/Vitamin E & Aloe Vera - Set of 30 Colors. Wow Christine! COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer "not for use around the eyes." The suit charges that ColourPop knew that the products were unsafe for use around the eyes but nevertheless marketed the items as safe "without warning consumers of the known dangers." thanks a lot no one is talking openly about it. Colourpop Review 2022 - Is ColourPop Legit? - BrandRated No, your eyes probably won't fall out but the chances of giving yourself a sty or other serious reaction dramatically increase (there's a reason we don't keep mascara for years, and those are formulated for eyes). My products have not yet arrived at my house and I have waited more than 20 days. Youll primarily be looking for this ingredient: polyethylene terephthalate. Can ColourPop lip products be used on eyelids? : MakeupAddiction - Reddit Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. At best, you risk mild eye irritation. The ultimate dreamy collection full of lavenders and violets , for soft and naturally defined lashes, this is your go-to black mascara, add a touch of definition with our newest brown mascara, A dreamy lavender palette full of serene shades , Be an angel with this bright silvery lavender with silver pin points , Glow on with this soft silvery cool-toned lavender, A true pinky lavender with pink, silver, teal & violet pin points , Swipe on this soft silvery lavender with silver, pink & violet pin points , Supercharged metallic vivid violet with a blue duo chrome flip! Is glitter safe for your eyes? Your Guide to Cosmetic Glitter (2020) As adults, we can probably deduce for ourselves that putting chunks of glitter near our eyes has some inherent risks that younger kids wouldnt think about. The concept that industries who profit from a product should be the ones regulate it which is the M.O. ColourPop Oh Snap Lippie Pencil. I really appreciate the work you put in to researching glitter in eye products, because it can feel so daunting as a layperson to sort through all the information from the FDA & the EU. The eyeliner has a cartridge of .55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. There are some derivatives like polybutylene, but it likely will have terephthalate with it. Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. This particular formula may work better for simple lines along your lashes. The product uses a long-wearing formula, and it features a unique blend of softer powders that adheres to your eyes with ease and gives a soft-focus effect while blending smoothly and evenly. The bit about to be safe when consumers use them according to their labeling, or as they are customarily used. is very interesting. The concealer also features Silica that gives your face a glow by oxygenating your skin and increasing the transportation of nutrients to your skin. Thank you! I might be allergic to ColourPop products! Thank you for posting about it and Im glad youre okay. I found PET glitter in newer releases like Marc Jacobs See-quins (not all shades but a fair amount), and even Pat McGraths Bronze Blaze (from the Bronze Seduction Palette) includes PET glitter. After some months (I dont remember exactly how long it was) I started finding it occasionally in other products. Find the top recommendations as voted by our Editor and community members here! Would you please be able to weigh in with your thoughts always love your insight and analysis of these topics! When you make a purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. I have some that I think are really cute from Shroud (formerly Strobe) Cosmetics, but because of concern for my eyes and the difficulty of removal, Ive been using them on my lips. Best of ColourPop Best Selling Palettes; Best Selling Eyes; Best Selling Lips; Best Selling Face; . A high percentage of people who use the products from this company are blown away with their results. Aside from the health concerns, its kind of odd to me that microbeads have become verboten but PET based glitters remain popular. There are alternatives to using plastic glitter, like synthetic fluorophlogopite (which is lab-made mica) and borosilicates, which are two ways Lush replaced plastic glitter in their products, that have widespread usage in cosmetics already. It seemed innocuous enough. Size: OS Colourpop. Some popular products that use one or both that are very sparkly: Pat McGrath Astral Solstice, Kaja Shimmer Trios, ColourPop Eyeshadows, ColourPop Sequin Super Shock Shadow, Hourglass Scattered Light Eyeshadows, MAC Dazzleshadows, and Urban Decay Moondust Eyeshadowsjust to name a few. I reached out to the FDA via their online contact form on January 14th, 2020: I wanted to inquire whether glitter, Polyethylene Terephthalate, is an approved ingredient for eye cosmetics, such as eye liner, eye shadow, and so forth. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an , lilac dreams come true with our newest 9 pan palette , Create dreamy looks with this purple trio , Good vibes only with this 9-pan palette , Brighten up with this vivid violet with hot pink + purple pin points , A warm rust with a blue-green duo chrome finish in our famous formula . bicicletarosa. If you have general feedback, I wear contacts and Ive suffered from irritation. Late to this conversation, but I can tell you love research, Christine. Only a sensation of grittiness if any fallout gets in my eye when I use that shade or the similarly textured Gilty Pleasure. So I spoke with two cosmetic chemists to get the factscan you use lip liner as eyeliner and vice versa? While I dont feel any personal need to be using large glitter on my eyes, Im thankful for your research into this. Thank you for the work you put into this! Thanks to their Instagram account and beauty bloggers, the company exploded onto the makeup scene and managed to secure collaborations with social media celebrities to help them grow, including Alexis Ren, Karrueche Tran, and Isabelle Fuhrman. Our ColourPop review concludes by recommending this company because it is a reliable brand that offers high-quality products, great deals, and the website provides a good user experience. Reviewers complaining about ColourPop most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and phone number problems. It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. Unfortunately, the yellow liner is incredibly streaky. there are things like mica, but that isn't glitter. participate respectfully. The founders of ColourPop are siblings John and Laura Nelson, who originally branched out from Spatz Laboratories (their fathers makeup company) to launch Seed Beauty. Not worth it. Created with Sketch. And the UK just banned over a thousand ingredients while the U.S. banned about 30. Additionally, ColourPop BFF Eyeliner contains Caprylyl Glycol, an ingredient that works as a preservative and prevents bacteria from growing to spoil the formula. Support us by Sharing It! I know the beauty community is a force to be reckoned with when they team up. It was developed here in British Columbia 30+ years ago by London Eye Center. Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. However, you need to pair ColourPop BFF Eyeliner with BFF mascara if you want to complete your look. Its a bit confusing, but interesting and very helpful. Mascara. Per my doctors notes and what he told me, it was a plastic particle that was removed. Nail Polish. Where can I purchase Colourpop products and how can I be sure that Colourpop products are real? Thank you? During this time, we will allow glitter and mica-based composite pigments to be released with comment when presented for importation into the US. Also, high amounts of ingredients like fats, alcohol and waxes in lip liner, aren't exactly safe to use on eyes, per StyleCheer. Highly pigmented super bendable powders in many beautiful colors. Lately, it seems like every brand is coming out with their version of a liquid lipstick, and I'm generally a fan of liquid lipstick formulas they dry to a flat matte finish and are super long wearing. Thank you ? Thank you so much for this thorough and fantastically researched overview! In terms of colors, a nude lip liner in a neutral hue close to the natural shade of your lips is good to have on hand, while a lip liner in brown gives you that nostalgic '90s look. To me, that would imply that an eyeshadow palette being used as an eyeshadow palette should be safe. Look no further than Temptalia's Swatch Gallery. expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up ColourPop BFF Eyeliner is available in various colors such as white, canary yellow, true black, deep sapphire, dark brown, and bright bubblegum pink. Support Temptalia by shopping the retailers below! I live in Europe so it isn't easy to get Colorpop productsI was prepared to pay customs fees of course, I knew I had to. BTW, I think you may be missing a clause after The FDAs position . We also ensure all reviews are published without moderation. We would not have the growing waste and pollution if thought and safety was the standard and priority. You can purchase ColourPop Cosmetics on colourpop.com and at Ulta Beautys site ulta.com. When I went to take the last one out, it rolled up into my eyelid and I freaked out trying to figure out how I was going to get it out..it took me an hour and it was rolled up in my eye but thankfully it came out without issues after I calmed down. I occasionally get into researching about something thoroughly like you do (I chuckled with empathy at your reply to kjh The hours Ive spent with my eyes almost glazed over and two separate windows with 30-40 tabs open in each for the last three days trying to find clarity), but your results and conclusions (so thoughtfully and eloquently put) helps thousands of women and I commend you for that! Light Medium, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. Well that was a heck of a rabbit hole you jumped into. And disappointment. The website saysFor maximum coverage: Use fingertip and tap shadow onto EYE liduse a flat synthetic brushthroughout the crease of the EYE and finally, ***not intended for the eye area. This satin-finish bronzer comes in a 7-gram container, and you can apply it onto your jawline, temples, and cheeks for the perfect bronzed look. Thank you for all your hard work. Thanks for making sure your readers are informed about the products they purchase (or in some cases, ones we dont purchase.) ColourPop Lippie Pencils - Reviews | MakeupAlley Many cosmetics companies rely on consumer ignorance about potential hazards. Clearly I dont deliberately eat glitter, but its inevitable that a small amount gets swallowed over the course of talking and drinking and I actually do wear glitter lips semi-regularly. Approved for use: Eyes Lips, Face (but please use caution around the eyes). According toStyleCheer, it's important to be aware that while lip and eyeliners appear to be the same, they have different key ingredients and those ingredients make a huge difference. Thank you for sharing this experience. I ordered a FULL Mandalorian set. Hyaluronic acid can also help lessen the redness and visible appearance of acne and protect your skin, which is helpful for acne-prone skin. Thanks, Christina! Is there any danger in doing this? I feel sorry for runway models who dont really get much of a choice when someone decides they need to be wearing craft glitter on their eyes on the runway to get a look. from. Moondust doesnt include plastic glitter from what I recall, but you can always check the ingredient list UD is pretty good about posting theirs! Also, any color additives used in cosmetics must be approved by FDA. FDA on Makeup. She never answered my question why they couldnt send it. The U.S. pales in comparison of other countries. , Be different with this shimmering sheer icy blue! Im sorry you had this happen to you but Im glad you are able to bring awareness to it. It helps to hydrate the outer layers of your skin, hence improving your skins appearance to give it a more radiant and youthful look without adding oil. Trustpilot gave ColourPop a 3.9-average score out of 38,786, with the majority of consumers saying that they love the fact that their products are affordable, effective, cruelty-free, and easy to use. Long time reader now subscribed. Look to see if any shades between two palettes are known dupes. There are certain ingredients that are prohibited from use, and there are color additives that have limited or restricted use. I will be using a Qtip along my lashlines first before cotton pads to sweep the rest away. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. It is important to note that not approved doesnt necessarily mean not safe but it doesnt mean that it is safe either. . Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this editorial Christine! Both of the CIR reports seem to confirm safety based on present practices of use and concentration by the industry; the tone of the report on PET glitter read to me that they were trying to establish its safety. Synthetic fluorphlogopite is supposed to have a more uniform finish which does not contain any sharp edges (per Lush). (Please find CosIng database results here for borosilicate glasses.) We imagine, develop, test and manufacture all under one roof for next level colour + formulas. Nothing quite like having an up close and personal run-in with PET glitter to cause one to look deeper into its potential hazards! Thank you for your meticulous investigation! Very Light, Olive, cool undertones. That product is in a lot fewer shadows and Im pretty sure that the colors that have them are the ones that bother my eyes if theres any fallout. Lastly, the brand offers a plethora of safe payment methods, allowing you to choose the option you prefer. As per a certain company with many releases including more push on plastic glitter- do you think companies care your safety or your coin? for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't I wasnt able to find any pending petitions regarding glitter, and you can also view final rules regarding color additives (generally) here. Normal skin. Ad Choices. If any professional makeup artists are using craft glitter on other people thats a real problem, much bigger than PET glitter. If product enters eye, rinse with water. Lip balm with SPF; Other. Too firm and it won't lay down enough pigment and will be drying to the lips. It might also be something where if the first ingredient contains it then that might be more bothersome vs. deeper on the list! I love Colourpop eyeshadow palettes, and eye makeup! The Foundation Matrix is designed to help. Their courteous customer support team is available between Monday and Friday from 8 a.m. 5 p.m. PST, and they will reply to your query within 48 business hours. Normal skin. I think brands should just not use plastic glitter or any other kind there are so many other, much safer finishes to use. FWIW, she thinks very highly of the Beauty Brains scientists, and their blog and podcast. Not to worry -- we can still help! This is yet another example of why you are the best beauty blogger in the blogosphere!